The wisdom (or stupidity) of the investment crowd: A reality check


Exactly 3 years ago, there was a thread shared on X (back then Twitter) – “Top 20 stocks that have 50x potential”.

This list was based on 700+ responses from other Twitter users, and I thought it was a solid representation of what the average investor was excited about, back then. So, I bookmarked the thread, and here we are, three years later, ready to have a look at the wisdom (or stupidity) of the investment crowd.

But before I start, do not forget, that the sentiment at that time was very positive. The S&P500 was up over 90% in a bit over a year, since the pandemic low back in March 2020.

Company name How it was described Ticker % change
Alteryx Big Data Analytics AYX -39%
Boston Omaha Berkshire Hathaway 2.0 BOMN 6%
Beyond meat Plant-based meat BYND -95%
Desktop Metals 3D Printing DM -95%
ContextLogic Discount e-commerce WISH -98%
Fiverr Online freelance marketplace FVRR -90%
Global-E Software for internatiocal e-commerce GLBE -38%
Jumia E-commerce in Africa JMIA -47%
Lemonade Next-gen insurance LMND -74%
Upstart Credit scores 2.0 UPST -76%
Latch Hardware/software for property management LTCH -97%
Nano-X Imaging Bring medical imaging to the world NNOX -71%
Origin Materials Carbon negative plastic ORGN -85%
Open Door Real estate iBuying OPEN -82%
Sofi Technologies Digital financial services SOFI -50%
Redfin Real Estate 2.0 & iBuying RDFN -86%
Ozon e-Commerce in Russia Ozon Delisted
Virgin Galactic Space tourism SPCE -99%
Twist Biosciences DNA on demand TWST -56%
YETI High-quality outdoor gear YETI -57%
Average -70%
S&P500 28%

The table shows the performance of these “top 20 stocks that have 50x potential” and as you can see, the average decline was a staggering 70%, compared to the S&P500’s gain of 28% over the same period. Not only that, but all of the 20 stocks underperformed the index.

The reality is, that it is easy to look like a genius in a bull market. Positive sentiment drives stock prices up, and it hides the underlying weaknesses. The fear of missing out adds more fuel to the fire. But also, there was fuel in the form of stimulus checks.

However, this doesn’t last forever and market conditions change. When that happens, risky investments and poor strategies are exposed, and those following the crowd without doing their homework, eventually learn a harsh lesson, as we’ll see in this perfect example.

The dramatic decline in these stocks serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of following the crowd in investing. Despite the initial optimism and promising potential, the reality has been a harsh lesson in the importance of thorough research. As Warren Buffett said, only when the tide goes out do you discover who has been swimming naked.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *